
  • flinders.edu.au
  • Staff
  • Students
  • Library
Flinders University Logo Flinders University Logo
  • New students

    Getting started

    • New students - Start here
    • Accept offer
    • Orientation
    • Credit transfer
    • Ready2Go?
    • Find your college
    • Your FAN
    • Okta

    Higher degree by research

    • Apply for a higher degree by research
    • Start your higher degree by research
    • HDR online induction
    Student System
    Orientation planner
    Compass
  • My course

    My course

    • Course rules & topics
    • Manage your enrolment
    • Timetables
    • Textbooks
    • Exams, assessments and results
    • Academic Progress
    • GPA calculator
    • Graduation
    • Internal transfer
    • Prizes and awards
    • Summer topics
    • Transnational Education (TNE) Students
    • Academic integrity
    • Graduate qualities

    Careers and opportunities

    • Student placements (WIL)
    • Careers & employability
    • Horizon Professional Development Award
    • Study abroad
    • Apply for honours year
    • Further study
    • Apply for a higher degree by research

    Higher degree by research

    • HDR home
    • Degree management
    • Progression and milestones
    • Examinations and completions
    • HDR development
    • Events and awards
    FLO
    Student System
    Compass
    Inspire
  • Support & services

    Health & wellbeing

    • Health services
    • Counselling services
    • Disability services
    • BetterU
    • Oasis Student Community Wellbeing Centre
    • Sport & fitness
    • Student Success & Wellbeing Advisors

    Study & learning

    • Academic advocacy
    • Studiosity online support
    • Learning Lounge
    • English language support
    • Study guides
    • Library
    • FLO Help
    • Student Learning Support Service
    • Elite athletes study support
    • Defence reserves study support

    Other support & services

    • Indigenous student services
    • International student services
    • Careers and employability
    • Legal advice
    • Financial advocacy
    • Financial support and scholarships
    • Flinders Connect

    IT & technology

    • Student systems and software
    • Email
    • Wi-Fi (eduroam)
    • Computers and printers on campus
    • Multi-factor authentication
    View all support & services
    Ask Flinders
    Flinders Support Network
    Support for Students
  • Uni life

    Campuses and facilities

    • Bedford Park campus
    • Tonsley campus
    • City Campus
    • Regional SA locations
    • Northern Territory campuses
    • Campus security
    • Accommodation
    • Flinders University Museum of Art (FUMA)

    Student news

    • Ping! all student newsletter
    • Empire Times Magazine
    • Student Stories

    Get involved

    • Get involved overview
    • Clubs & societies
    • Sport & fitness
    • FUSA events
    • Join the Student View Group
    • Join the student association (FUSA)
    • Become an Inspire mentor
    • Become a wellbeing ambassador
    • The Good Vibes Experiment
    • Flinders Learning Experience Conversations

    Colleges

    • College of Business, Government and Law
    • College of Education, Psychology and Social Work
    • College of Humanities, Arts and Social Sciences
    • College of Medicine and Public Health
    • College of Nursing and Health Sciences
    • College of Science and Engineering
  • Finance & admin

    Finance and fees

    • Financial advice, emergency loans and grants
    • Scholarships
    • Fees, payments and refunds
    • Student Services & Amenities Fee (SSAF)
    • Domestic student financial assistance
    • International student financial assistance
    • Financial advocacy

    Admin & documents

    • Government compliance
    • My eQuals
    • Transcripts
    • AHEGS
    • Testamurs
    • Student ID cards
    • Justice of the Peace
    • Important dates
    • Policy

    Insurance

    • Student travel insurance
    • Student insurance
    Student System
    Online payments
    Ask Flinders
  • Feedback & rights

    Feedback

    • Ideas & feedback
    • Student Evaluation of Teaching (SET)
    • Success report
    • Surveys and Focus Groups

    My rights & policies

    • Safety on campus
    • Student policies and procedures
    • Equal opportunity & diversity
    • Work, Health and safety (WHS)

    Complaints

    • Complaints and appeals
  • flinders.edu.au
  • Staff
  • Students
  • Library
  • You have no saved courses.

    Continue to explore your course options.

     
    Explore our courses

    Your saved courses

    {{{courseName}}}
    mail_outline
    delete
    View all saved courses
  • Quick links 
    • Compass
    • Flinders dashboard (Okta)
    • Calendar and key dates
    • Ask Flinders
    • Student System
    • Flinders Learning Online (FLO)
    • Email login
    • Parking: Bedford Park
    • Campus map: Bedford Park
    • Policy library
    • Campus bus
    • Shop Flinders merchandise

 

How is a thesis examined?

My course HDR HDR examinations and completions How is a thesis examined?

HDR examinations and completions

    Overview Preparing for HDR thesis submission How is a thesis examined? Submitting your thesis for examination Thesis amendments after your examination Your thesis: final steps Examination forms Thesis printing

All higher degree by research students should be aware of the HDR Policy and HDR Examination Procedures applicable to the examination of a thesis.


General considerations

You are not only examined on the basis of your understanding of a body of existing knowledge but will be also be examined by individuals who must judge the approach to research, construction of hypotheses, argument and analysis. If the degree is awarded, you will become the peer of the examiners.

 

Appointment of examiners keyboard_arrow_up

Two examiners are appointed for a research masters or doctoral degree thesis, both of whom must be external to the University, from different institutions, and have no actual, potential or perceived conflicts of interest with you, your supervisors or each other.

Examiners will be experts of international standing in the discipline and will be active in research/scholarship thus ensuring that their knowledge of the field or area of professional practice is current. They must hold a qualification equivalent to or higher than the degree for which the thesis is being examined.

The appointment of the examiners must be approved by the College and the Office of Graduate Research. Before examiners are approved, you are given the opportunity to object to any examiners who you do NOT wish to examine your thesis. This can be done on your intention to submit milestone in Inspire.

Examiners identities are not revealed to you until after the examination process, and only if the examiner does not want to remain anonymous.  

More detailed information about the appointment of examiners can be found in HDR Policy and HDR Examination Procedures. 

Examination process keyboard_arrow_up

An examiner is given 6 weeks to examine your thesis, however at times this can be delayed depending on the individual circumstances of the examiner. Once both of your examiners' reports are received they will be considered by the Dean of Graduate Research and you will be notified of the results. 

Examiners will be asked to write and upload a written report on the quality of the thesis and recommend one of the following grades in Inspire:

A: Award: that the degree should be awarded, subject to satisfying any coursework requirements (if applicable);
B:

Award: that the degree should be awarded, subject to the completion of minor amendments to the thesis (specified by the examiner) to be carried out to the satisfaction of the supervisor, college HDR coordinator and the Dean of Graduate Research and subject to satisfying any coursework requirements (if applicable);

Note: Minor amendments may include the correction of spelling or typographical errors and small changes to the text. 

C:

Award: that the degree should be awarded, subject to the completion of major amendments to the thesis (specified by the examiner) to be carried out to the satisfaction of the supervisor, college HDR coordinator and the Dean of Graduate Research and subject to satisfying any coursework requirements (if applicable); 

Note: Major amendments apply when an examiner is assured that the thesis is sound, but the amendments suggest changes to the structure and/or substance of some chapters of the thesis to improve the thesis without re-examination. 

D: Resubmit: that the degree should not be awarded but the student should be permitted to revise and resubmit the thesis for re-examination. A thesis may be resubmitted for examination only once;
E: Award alternate degree: that in the case of a student who has submitted a thesis for the degree of PhD or professional doctorate an appropriate masters degree or designated exit award should be awarded; 
F: Non Award: that the degree should not be awarded and the student should not be allowed to present for the degree again. 

Further details can be found in the HDR Policy and HDR Examination Procedures.

Consideration of examiners' report keyboard_arrow_up

When the examiners agree

After receiving the examiners' reports, the Dean of Graduate Research determines the final outcome of the examination. If both examiners have recommended the award of the degree without any amendments (A grade), the Dean of Graduate Research will recommend that the degree be awarded.

If both examiners have recommended the award of the degree subject to minor or major amendments (B or C grade), or if one examiner recommends that the thesis be passed, and the other recommends that the thesis be passed subject to minor or major amendments (B or C grade), your supervisor and the HDR Coordinator of your College (or nominee) ensures that the amendments are made. The Dean of Graduate Research will then normally recommend the award of the degree.

If both examiners are unanimous in making any of the other remaining recommendations above (D, E or F grades), the examiners' reports are then referred to the University Higher Degrees Research Committee (UHDRC), which will make a decision on the outcome of the examination.


When the examiners don't agree

When examiners are not unanimous in making any other recommendations above, you and your supervisor will be provided with copies of the examiner reports. In consultation with you, your supervisor will be invited to write a statement in response to the differing examiner recommendations. Your examination will be then be referred to the University Higher Degrees Research Committee (UHDRC) who will determine your final examination result. The UHDRC may engage a third examiner to provide the committee with additional expertise and insight. 

The following  examination diagram and matrix may be helpful tools to assist with understanding this process.

  • Examinations diagram
  • HDR examination matrix
Student examination appeals keyboard_arrow_up

You can appeal your examination grade to the Student Appeals Committee if you fall into one of the categories below: 

  1. You received divergent results and a decision was made by the URHDC; 
  2. You received an (E) Award Alternate Degree or (F) Non-Award; or
  3. You are able to provide documented evidence of a flaw in the examination process, such as prejudice or bias on the part of one or more examiners. 

 An appeal may only be made on one or more of the following grounds:

  • The appropriate policy was not adhered to or correct procedures were not followed in considering the matter; 
  • The decision was made without due regard to facts, evidence or circumstances.

For further information on appeals refer to the HDR Policy and HDR Examination Procedures. 

Need help?

If you have any questions related to our HDR examination process or require any additional information, please don't hesistate to contact us. 

Ask Flinders HDR Portal

(08) 8201 3854

Flinders University Logo

Sturt Rd, Bedford Park
South Australia 5042

Student help and requests

  • Glossary
  • Flinders website
  • Staff Portal

Follow Flinders

Facebook - Flinders University
Instagram - Flinders University
TikTok - Flinders University
LinkedIn - Flinders University
Bluesky - Flinders University
YouTube - Flinders University
Brand SA logo Innovative Research University logo Indigenous communities

Website feedback and requests

Disclaimer

Accessibility

Privacy

CRICOS Provider: 00114A      TEQSA Provider ID: PRV12097      TEQSA category: Australian University

Last Updated: 15 Jan 2021

FOREVER FEARLESS

This website uses cookies

Flinders University uses cookies to ensure website functionality, personalisation and a variety of purposes as set out in its website privacy statement. This statement explains cookies and their use by Flinders.

If you consent to the use of our cookies then please click the button below:

Accept all cookies and continue

If you do not consent to the use of all our cookies then please click the button below. Clicking this button will result in all cookies being rejected except for those that are required for essential functionality on our website.

Reject all non-essential cookies and continue